Internet Shakespeare Editions


Macbeth - The Guthrie's 50th

by Bruce Brandt. Written on 2010-04-26. Published in Reviews from the ISE Chronicle.

For the production Macbeth (2010, Guthrie Theater, USA)

This production of Macbeth is the Guthrie始s 50th Shakespeare production. It began not with the weird sisters speaking of the “hurlyburly,” nor with King Duncan receiving reports from the battlefield, but with the battle itself. Soldiers burst onto the stage, some descending on ropes that dropped from the fly space; others charging in from stage left and right. The sound of explosions and gunfire filled the theater. As the fighting subsided, Duncan and his staff entered and he received the report from the wounded sergeant. From there the play proceeded at a rapid pace. Played without a break, the entire performance lasted just two hours and five minutes.

It was acted on the Guthrie始s Wurtele Thrust Stage, and with the exception of a gold wall that descended for the scenes in the palace, the set remained constant throughout the performance. At the back of the stage was the façade of a heavily damaged neo-classical style building with huge columns, and around the sides of the stage lay damaged furniture and other household goods, presumably pulled or tossed from the building. Everything was gray. Presumably the building had been damaged or destroyed in the ongoing fighting that the kingdom had undergone. In the Guthrie始s online notes for the performance (at, the set and costume designer, Monica Frawley, spoke of Hitler始s and Mussolini始s professed love of art (the neoclassical structure) and the destruction that they actually wrought on civilization. One doubts that such a specific association would have occurred to many in the audience without the prompting of her comment, but the set design was certainly effective in suggesting a depressed and damaged kingdom, one beset by war both at the beginning and end of the play, and one suffering under the rule of a tyrant.

The action was set in the mid-twentieth century, although Frawley始s notes indicated that she had deliberately mixed costumes from different times during that period to give the play a more generic and timeless feeling. The costumes and props were both attractive and effective, although after the spectacular display of weaponry in the opening, it seemed odd for all of the subsequent fighting to be done only with knives. Perhaps, though, most theatergoers would not notice, and as Horatio tells Hamlet, “Twere to consider too curiously to consider so.”

The actors playing Macbeth and Lady Macbeth (Erik Heger and Michelle O始Neill) are both physically attractive, and the production emphasizes the Macbeths始 love, and lust, for each other. In their first scene together, Macbeth strips off his shirt immediately upon returning home, and the couple ends up embracing passionately on the floor. The play fully realizes the idea that Lady Macbeth始s sway over her husband is rooted in her sexuality.

A number of Joe Dowling始s directorial decisions were interesting. For example, after Ross tells Macduff that he will go to Scone to see the coronation, the scene shifts to Scone, and Macbeth始s coronation is staged with full pomp and ceremony. The production also offers a simple answer to the identity of the third murderer. The servant who brings in the two murderers is Seyton, and after the two are dismissed, Macbeth motions for Seyton to follow them. Strangely, though, Fleance escapes death precisely because Seyton, who could have easily killed him, lets him go. Though there is no textual warrant for this decision, it would appear that there are limits to what even the most loyal of servants will do. The special effects of the witches始 conjuring scene created a strikingly beautiful scene. The “cauldron” was an open trap, through which the apparitions appeared. The dry-ice fog machines created a thick layer of fog, perhaps eight-inches high, which flowed across the stage and poured into the open trap, like river water forming a waterfall. There was no beheading at the end. Malcolm enters immediately after Macduff has slain Macbeth, and Macduff始s line “Behold where stands / Th始usurper始s cursèd head” is spoken while pointing to the body.

Clearly there was much that worked well in this performance of Macbeth, and much to think about. However, speaking as one who has seen almost all of the Guthrie始s Shakespeare productions for many years, and been enthralled by most of them, this production was disappointing. Much was simply too static. Despite the beauty of the cauldron scene始s staging, the witches themselves were not dynamic. One suspects that this fault came from the director始s desire to emphasize the ritualistic side of magic, but the result was slow and mechanical. They did not produce the aura of equivocating evil that is required of them. Similarly, the doctor should have been much more fearful for her own life once she (in this production) has pierced the secret of Lady Macbeth始s madness. She was too low key. She needs to hide her fear from Macbeth, but not from the audience. Surprisingly for the Guthrie, language sometimes seemed a stumblingly block. Particularly with the younger actors, there was a tendency to overemphasize the cadence of the blank verse. Macbeth始s later soliloquies also had a tendency to be spoken as ruminative and slow, rather than as filled with powerful emotion. Again, one suspects that directorial vision underlay the actor始s approach.